Search Hotels Near Algonquian Waters Lake, West Milford

"The 1st room was already occupied. 2nd room was hot! A/C was not working. Fixed in about an hour. The layout of the hotel was very odd. Lots of doors. Overall not a horrible stay."

"Great experience would absolutely stay there again and recommend it to others"

"Efficient, clean and in a prime spot "

"Optimal location to Carnegie Hall. Nice gym. Comfortable beds. Very clean. Overall, a nice stay."

"I loved this hotel. It’s small, unique and the bakery is amazing!!! Location is also fantastic. I won’t be staying anywhere else in NYC from now on."

"At check-in, the front desk person was rogue and rude. In my room on the towel I put on the floor in the bathroom a few hours later I noticed a mouse dropping on my towel on the floor. The coffee maker had bits of either coffee or loose tea bag bits in it because the water contain those dark bits in it. The toilet would not flush properly. I was offered another room the next day for a free state. That room was smaller than the original room I paid for. The bathroom was beat up and nasty looking like it needed a overhaul. Overall a very terrible stay and a waste of my money."

"Large and welcoming lobby. Exceptionally helpful front desk and other lobby staff. Three restaurants at the property - we visited the diner-type restaurant which was as you'd expect but more efficient. Got a room upgrade - to a huge, beautiful room with expansive view and even a balcony! Would definitely stay here again."

"First of all, I have no words how helpful and welcoming the staff is. Everyone were so polite and helpful. Second thing, if you like and you miss old charm of the hotels back in a day (like I do) this is it. Would definitely consider staying with them again."

"Great location."