Car Rentals in Shelter Island, USA

Search and Compare from Car Companies in Shelter Island

Photo by Brian V. Rowe
    protection illustration

    Change your mind

    Penalty-free cancellation on many/select car hire
    trophy illustration

    Treat yourself

    Members save 10% or more on over 1 million car hire
    package illustration

    Shop smart

    Compare car suppliers to unlock big savings

Frequently asked questions

What happens if I need to cancel my Shelter Island car reservation?
Don't stress. You should receive all of your money back if you let us know a minimum of six hours prior to pickup. Your itinerary contains information about this, and so does our Customer Service Portal. Not all bookings qualify for a refund though, so you may want to check the rental agreement.
What are the top things to do on Shelter Island?
There are so many things to do on and around Shelter Island. And when you hop behind the wheel of your rental car, you can discover them at your leisure. You'll want to add these popular places to your travel schedule:

  • Mashomack Preserve is a pleasant spot to take a breather. Enjoy a picnic, toss a Frisbee around or just lie on the cool grass and close your eyes for a while.
  • Find out who can get the best score as you make your way around the challenging holes of Shelter Island Whale's Tail. It's trickier than it looks!
  • Nothing gives us a glimpse into the past quite like old buildings. Discover a thing or two about the area's fascinating history at Sylvester Manor.

Why should I rent a Shelter Island car with Expedia?
From member exclusive discounts to our handy package deals, there are so many reasons to rent your ride with Expedia. Making your way to Shelter Island? There are car rental companies to take your pick of, with lots of vehicles to suit every style and budget. If you want to save more, bundle your car rental with your hotel and flights. Ready to hit the road? We're ready to help get you on your way.
How do I find the best car rental deals on Shelter Island with Expedia?
Whatever class of wheels you're searching for, Expedia will help you find the best deal. Simply compare offers from leading rental providers and book the option that's perfect for you. Want to drive away with even bigger savings? Combine your Shelter Island car rental with flight or hotel bookings.
How old do you have to be to rent a car on Shelter Island?
Drivers must be at least 21. Motoring around in a rental car is the best way to see Shelter Island, but take note that a daily surcharge usually applies to younger drivers. A higher age limit also often applies to the rental of luxury vehicles and SUVs. Have a good read through the fine print before making a booking.
What do you need to rent a car on Shelter Island?
The main things are a current driver's license and credit card. Both will need to be in the driver's name. Got more than one motorist in your group? They must also be present at the time of collection and provide the same documents. Check your rental policy for information about any auto insurance you may need as well.
Can I rent a car for a month or longer on Shelter Island?
You sure can. With Expedia's competitive long-term car rental deals, you don't have to rush your Shelter Island adventure. Choose your dates, reserve your favorite ride and then explore the coastal roads at your leisure.
Where can I find a Shelter Island car rental if I am younger than 25?
Be sure to check the age policy of the Shelter Island rental provider you're considering. Rental companies usually apply a young renter surcharge to people between the ages of 21 and 24, so make sure you know how much this cost is. No one enjoys being taken by surprise at the rental counter, so always read through the fine print before locking in your booking.