Search Hotels in Starke Peninsula, Milwaukee

"Overall, I had a great experience. The staff was helpful, professional, and accommodating throughout my stay. The continental breakfast was decent as well. The only downside was the pool area, which was very small for the amount of guests staying there. It honestly felt more like a large hot tub converted into a pool. Everything was peaceful during the week, but once the weekend came and more younger guests and children arrived, the atmosphere became much louder. There were children running through the hallways, knocking on doors and running away late at night, yelling in the halls, and leaving ice throughout the hallway areas. I was traveling with a newborn who is not even a month old yet, so it became difficult at times and I did have to make a few complaints. Despite that, I would still return because overall the stay itself and the staff were very good."

"Always a great experience at Potowatomi! Great rooms, great food, great fun!!"

"M"

"Okay"

"Good food&great staff"

"I love it here !!!!"

"Staff super friendly, room was decent, area quiet and safe. Continued issues with my keys. Room didn’t have a coffee/tea pot as stated. That was quite disappointing! Room was completely empty, not a fork, dish,cup, napkin."

"I love staying here. Beautiful art deco lobby with marble flooring and original light fixtures. They have the coffee shop open in the morning and the barn restaurant for the evening. There's a shuttle to take you anywhere nearby within 3 miles. Staff was friendly and parking was easy. Good size hotel. "

"I would like o recognize a member of the breakfast staff. She was working on 4/27/2026. I believe her name was Judy. She was bussing tables and making sure everything was stocked in the breakfast area, but when the person who makes omelets wasn’t there to help us, she stepped in and did an amazing job! What a great team player!!"