Ruang duduk lobi
Cek ketersediaan

Ulasan untuk Chankam Boutique Hotel

4 out of 5
Chankam Boutique Hotel
7/2 Arak Rd., Soi 4. T.Phra Singh., A. Muang, Chiang Mai, Chiang Mai

Ulasan

9,0

Luar biasa

Penilaian 10 - Sangat Bagus. 153 dari 247 ulasan" "
Penilaian 8 - Bagus. 64 dari 247 ulasan" "
Penilaian 6 - Cukup Baik. 17 dari 247 ulasan" "
Penilaian 4 - Buruk. 7 dari 247 ulasan" "
Penilaian 2 - Sangat Buruk. 6 dari 247 ulasan" "

9,4/10

Kebersihan

9,0/10

Staf & layanan

8,2/10

Fasilitas

9,2/10

Kondisi & fasilitas properti

9,4/10

Ramah lingkungan

Ulasan

10/10 Sangat Bagus

Sammy

Traveler bisnis
Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, fasilitas, kondisi & fasilitas properti
Authentic, excellent service.
Menginap 3 malam pada bulan Januari 2024
Tanggapan dari Nok pada tanggal 29 Feb 2024
Thank you.

10/10 Sangat Bagus

Henry

Bepergian bersama keluarga
Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, fasilitas, kondisi & fasilitas properti
Beautiful boutique hotel in the heart of Old City Chiang Mai. The staff was wonderful and accommodating. The room was very nice and clean, with self service coffee/tea, minibar, and small balcony. Very easy walk to a variety of eateries, temples, the walking street market and other sights. Would definitely stay there again in the future!
Menginap 3 malam pada bulan Desember 2023
Tanggapan dari Nok pada tanggal 29 Feb 2024
Thank you.

10/10 Sangat Bagus

Michael

Bepergian dalam rombongan
Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, fasilitas, kondisi & fasilitas properti
Staff very helpful and accommodating. I will stay here again next Chiang Mai visit!
Menginap 2 malam pada bulan Desember 2023

10/10 Sangat Bagus

David

Disukai: Fasilitas, kondisi & fasilitas properti
I felt at home
Menginap 14 malam pada bulan Desember 2023

8/10 Bagus

Whitney

Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, kondisi & fasilitas properti, kenyamanan kamar
Menginap 3 malam pada bulan Desember 2023

10/10 Sangat Bagus

John, Federal Way

Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, fasilitas, kondisi & fasilitas properti
I loved my stay here so much that I booked to stay another night at the end of my trip! Lovely staff, comfortable and clean rooms, great location!
Menginap 1 malam pada bulan November 2023

4/10 Buruk

Andrew

Tidak Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, kondisi & fasilitas properti, kenyamanan kamar
Old and tired
Unfortunately the place is old and run down. The air conditioner in our room didn’t work and it over an hour to convince the night manger that there was a problem. It then took her another 30 minutes to find us another room even though we and travelling companion were the only ones staying there. We tried to breakfast one day but the chef was having the day off. We had to get up early the next day and did provide us with toast and coffee as requested. Overall disappointing.
Menginap 4 malam pada bulan Mei 2023
Tanggapan dari ์Nok pada tanggal 20 Mei 2023
We apologize for what happened. which that day was a very hot day. And our hotel would like to thank you for your comments about our hotel. We will bring it to improve urgently.

6/10 Cukup Baik

ernest

Menginap 11 malam pada bulan Oktober 2022
Tanggapan dari ์Nok pada tanggal 30 Apr 2023
Our hotel is pleased to improve. If you let us know of a problem.

10/10 Sangat Bagus

Virginia A

Traveler bisnis
Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, kondisi & fasilitas properti, kenyamanan kamar
Good stay
It was a great stay. The room was everything the site advertised. Would definitely stay there again.
Menginap 5 malam pada bulan Februari 2023
Tanggapan dari nok pada tanggal 10 Mar 2023
Thank you very much. The hotel hopes to take care of you again in Chiang Mai.

10/10 Sangat Bagus

Brooke

Bepergian bersama teman
Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, fasilitas, kondisi & fasilitas properti
The staff was lovely and helpful. I loved that it was on a quiet road yet 10 minute walk to most things. Pretty building and clean!
Menginap 3 malam pada bulan Februari 2023
Tanggapan dari nok pada tanggal 19 Feb 2023
thank you.

8/10 Bagus

Shou

Bepergian bersama teman
Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, fasilitas, kondisi & fasilitas properti
1) Friendly helpful staff 2) Unruly guest woke us up in the early hour
Menginap 6 malam pada bulan Februari 2023
Tanggapan dari ์Nok pada tanggal 11 Feb 2023
Thank you for the review.

10/10 Sangat Bagus

Harley

Disukai: Staf & layanan, fasilitas, kondisi & fasilitas properti
Menginap 17 malam pada bulan Januari 2023
Tanggapan dari ์Nok pada tanggal 10 Mar 2023
Thank you very much. The hotel hopes to take care of you again in Chiang Mai.

10/10 Sangat Bagus

SUMI

Bepergian bersama keluarga
Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, kondisi & fasilitas properti, kenyamanan kamar
만족해요
만족스러웠어요. 처음 2박만 예약했다가 3박추가했어요. 친절하고 조용했어요. 그렇지만 골목이 깊고, 호텔옆에 구멍가게 같은 곳에서 늦게까지 술을 마시는 현지인들이 있어서 조금 무서웠어요
Menginap 2 malam pada bulan Januari 2023
Tanggapan dari ์Nok pada tanggal 11 Feb 2023
Thank you

10/10 Sangat Bagus

Michelle

Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, kondisi & fasilitas properti, kenyamanan kamar
Loved Chankram
Our stay at Chankam was wonderful! The front desk staff were very helpful! Cute property like a bed n breakfast. 5 min walk to cafes and massage places. Out of the 3 weeks we spent in Thailand this was our favorite place.
Menginap 5 malam pada bulan Desember 2022
Tanggapan dari ์Nok pada tanggal 11 Feb 2023
Thank you. We are glad that you like our hotel.

10/10 Sangat Bagus

Sage

Bepergian dalam rombongan
Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, kondisi & fasilitas properti
Great place.
Menginap 3 malam pada bulan Desember 2022

8/10 Bagus

Weng

Bepergian bersama teman
Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, fasilitas, kondisi & fasilitas properti
A Standard room that is more spacious than others, with a Juliette balcony. The shower cubicle is roomy with strong spray. The location is within walkable of cafes, restaurants and tourists' spots
Tanggapan dari Nok pada tanggal 1 Des 2022
Thank you for staying with us and for your kind review and recommendation.

10/10 Sangat Bagus

Suwanakorn

Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, fasilitas, kondisi & fasilitas properti
They charge for every drink inside the room. If you don’t want to pay extra, don’t drink or have any extra items they provide. Otherwise, the room is nice and clean. The walking distance from the hotel to street food vendors is about 5 minutes, friendly staff. The hotel is also close to the airport. If you need a ride to the airport, let them know ahead of time.
Menginap 1 malam pada bulan Oktober 2022

10/10 Sangat Bagus

Kevin, Bangkok, Thailand

Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, fasilitas, kondisi & fasilitas properti
Wonderful boutique hotel in a quiet neighborhood, yet near the Sunday Night Market. Friendly owner, super comfortable bed.
Menginap 2 malam pada bulan Agustus 2020
Tanggapan dari Rinradee pada tanggal 9 Sep 2020
Thank you for staying with us and for your kind review and recommendation.

2/10 Sangat Buruk

Traveler terverifikasi

Tidak Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, fasilitas
Menginap 2 malam pada bulan Maret 2020
Tanggapan dari Rinradee pada tanggal 19 Mar 2020
Thank you for staying with us

10/10 Sangat Bagus

J4, DC

Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, fasilitas, kondisi & fasilitas properti
Property was very attractive and well-appointed. I liked it being on a small alley. Very quiet and pleasant oasis in the Old City. Very walkable. Great Thai BBQ on Arak Road, about a 10-minute walk from the hotel.
Menginap 3 malam pada bulan Maret 2020
Tanggapan dari Rinradee pada tanggal 9 Mar 2020
We are delighted to note that you had a pleasant experience on that your stay with us; and appreciate your valuable feedback Thank you once again for your review and for your patronage; and we are looking forward to welcoming you on your next stay with us. with kindest regards,

10/10 Sangat Bagus

Marion

Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, kondisi & fasilitas properti, kenyamanan kamar
Stay here!
I love this hotel, it is well situated, clean, delicious breakfast, staff are so kind. What made it so enjoyable was its personality. Wonderful decoration, woodworking details, vintage furniture, beautiful tile, local handcrafts. They greeted us with orange juice and refreshing, cool cloths.
Menginap 2 malam pada bulan Februari 2020
Tanggapan dari Rinradee pada tanggal 9 Mar 2020
We are delighted to note that you had a pleasant experience on that your stay with us; and appreciate your valuable feedback on our rooms and amenities as well as our services and welcome drink offerings. Thank you once again for your review and for your patronage; and we are looking forward to welcoming you on your next stay with us. with kindest regards,

2/10 Sangat Buruk

Traveler terverifikasi

Menginap 1 malam pada bulan Februari 2020
Tanggapan dari Rinradee pada tanggal 26 Feb 2020
Thank you for your review and we’re sorry to hear that your experience was not of the quality you expected. We would like the opportunity to investigate your feedback further.

10/10 Sangat Bagus

VK, Colorado

Bepergian dalam rombongan
Disukai: Kebersihan, fasilitas, kondisi & fasilitas properti
VERY friendly and accommodating staff. Power went out and did not come pack on our day of check out. The safe in the room did not work and wasn’t bolted down. The smoke detector flashed ALL night long. Bed super comfortable. Cute balcony and patio. Very safe luggage storage.
Menginap 2 malam pada bulan Februari 2020
Tanggapan dari Rinradee pada tanggal 25 Feb 2020
Thank you for staying with us and for your kind review and recommendation and we are looking forward to welcoming you on your next stay with us.

8/10 Bagus

Traveler terverifikasi

Bepergian dalam rombongan
Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, fasilitas, kondisi & fasilitas properti
It was a very nice hotel!! Super convenient location. Would have been nice to have a little more seating in the room, but other than that it was great!
Menginap 2 malam pada bulan Februari 2020
Tanggapan dari Rinradee pada tanggal 25 Feb 2020
Thank you for staying with us and for your kind review and recommendation and we are looking forward to welcoming you on your next stay with us.

10/10 Sangat Bagus

Basia, Edmonton, AB Canada

Bepergian bersama teman
Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, fasilitas, kondisi & fasilitas properti
Room was great, staff was amazing GREAT location just a 5 min walk to the main area so it was away from the hustle and bustle of old town but everything was Walkable. I would highly recommend
Menginap 5 malam pada bulan Februari 2020
Tanggapan dari Rinradee. pada tanggal 18 Feb 2020
Thank you for staying with us and for your kind review and recommendation. We are delighted to note that you had a pleasant experience on that your stay with us; and appreciate your valuable feedback on our rooms and our staff, Thank you once again for your review and for your patronage; and we are looking forward to welcoming you on your next stay with us.

4/10 Buruk

Traveler terverifikasi

Bepergian bersama keluarga
Disukai: Kondisi & fasilitas properti
Tidak Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, fasilitas
They don’t even give out instance coffee pack complimentary. There is only one staff in the evening so if we request some small stuff the only one staff at the reception has to come up to give our requested items which is odd.
Menginap 5 malam pada bulan Februari 2020
Tanggapan dari Rinradee pada tanggal 14 Feb 2020
Thank you for your feedback, We have coffee capsules for guests staying with us. Because the capsule coffee is of better quality than instant coffee, you can conveniently use the coffee machine in the room. And our staff will be at your service 24 hours. Although a small thing, We are very appreciate to service our value guests. Thank you again for stay with us and we look forward to welcoming you again.

10/10 Sangat Bagus

Traveler terverifikasi

Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, fasilitas, kondisi & fasilitas properti
This is a beautiful hotel and Rinradee the manageress is so welcoming and so helpful. The hotel is an oasis of calm in a busy city. The staff cannot do enough for you. It is a very comfortable hotel, we couldn’t wait to get back everyday and enjoy the super comfortable bed and beautiful crisp clean sheets! I look forward to staying at the Chankam boutique hotel again and thoroughly recommend it.
Menginap 7 malam pada bulan Januari 2020
Tanggapan dari Rinradee pada tanggal 11 Feb 2020
Thank you for staying with us and for your kind review and recommendation. We are delighted to note that you had a pleasant experience on that your stay with us; and appreciate your valuable feedback on our rooms and amenities Thank you once again for your review and for your patronage; and we are looking forward to welcoming you on your next stay with us. with kindest regards,

8/10 Bagus

Traveler terverifikasi

Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, fasilitas, kondisi & fasilitas properti
Menginap 1 malam pada bulan Februari 2020
Tanggapan dari rinradee pada tanggal 5 Feb 2020
Thank you for staying with us and for your kind review

10/10 Sangat Bagus

Traveler terverifikasi

Bepergian dalam rombongan
Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, kondisi & fasilitas properti, kenyamanan kamar
A very enjoyable stay
A very cute hotel! With a very friendly staff... one can also get bikes for free. Spacious rooms, in the old town but quiet, far from noise and crowd, excellent location.
Menginap 4 malam pada bulan Januari 2020
Tanggapan dari rinradee pada tanggal 4 Feb 2020
Thank you for staying with us and for your kind review and recommendation, We are looking forward to welcoming you on your next time.

10/10 Sangat Bagus

Chaeyun

Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, kondisi & fasilitas properti, kenyamanan kamar
직원이 매우 친절하고 자전거 대여가 가능해서 좋아요! 방도 깔끔합니다
Menginap 2 malam pada bulan Januari 2020
Tanggapan dari Rinradee pada tanggal 4 Feb 2020
Thank you for staying with us and for your kind review and recommendation, We are looking forward to welcoming you on your next time.

10/10 Sangat Bagus

Sungho

Traveler bisnis
Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, kondisi & fasilitas properti, kenyamanan kamar
Menginap 1 malam pada bulan Januari 2020
Tanggapan dari Rinradee pada tanggal 30 Jan 2020
Thank you for staying with us and for your kind review and recommendation. We are looking forward to welcoming you on your next stay with us.

8/10 Bagus

Eulalio Kevin

Bepergian bersama keluarga
Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, kondisi & fasilitas properti, kenyamanan kamar
Nice stay
Had a good stay and bfast was good
Menginap 1 malam pada bulan Januari 2020
Tanggapan dari rinradee pada tanggal 4 Feb 2020
Thank you for staying with us and for your kind review and recommendation, We are looking forward to welcoming you on your next time.

10/10 Sangat Bagus

Traveler terverifikasi

Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, fasilitas, kondisi & fasilitas properti
Menginap 1 malam pada bulan Januari 2020
Tanggapan dari rinradee pada tanggal 4 Feb 2020
Thank you for staying with us and for your kind review and recommendation, We are looking forward to welcoming you on your next time.

10/10 Sangat Bagus

Ian

Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, kondisi & fasilitas properti, kenyamanan kamar
Reasonable priced hotel. In the heart of the old town. You would need a taxi or GRAB (thai uber) to get around but they are very cheap. Room was comfortable and clean. Looks lovely. Staff were really helpful and near to the airport.
Menginap 1 malam pada bulan Januari 2020
Tanggapan dari Rinradee pada tanggal 22 Jan 2020
Thank you for staying with us. We appreciate your feedback and we hope you stay with us again in the future.

10/10 Sangat Bagus

Traveler terverifikasi

Bepergian bersama keluarga
Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, fasilitas, kondisi & fasilitas properti
These were the nicest people we encountered in Thailand
Menginap 5 malam pada bulan Desember 2019
Tanggapan dari Rinradee pada tanggal 10 Jan 2020
Thank you for staying with us and for your kind review and recommendation

10/10 Sangat Bagus

N.Naim, Kuala Lumpur

Bepergian bersama teman
Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, fasilitas, kondisi & fasilitas properti
Staff really friendly and helpful. Wifi connectivity was good. Hotel is clean & tidy. Location a bit far from main road, but OK if you prefer quiet place. Only minus point is the layout of room, which the wardrobe is inside the bathroom, so not convenience to get dress when bathroom in use. Could be better if there is coffee sachet provided in room(our room only have tea).
Menginap 2 malam pada bulan Desember 2019
Tanggapan dari Rinradee pada tanggal 27 Des 2019
Thank you for staying with us and for your kind review and recommendation.

10/10 Sangat Bagus

retsu, 広島

Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, fasilitas, kondisi & fasilitas properti
旧市街の静かな場所にありゆっくりすることができた。 どこかに出るには不便かもしれないが滞在するならこういう場所がいい。 何よりスタッフ全員の優しさが素晴らしかった。細やかな心遣いや配慮をしてくれる。 朝7時集合のツアーに参加するので朝食が食べられないなと思っていたところ、朝6時30分に用意をしてくれた。 またチェンマイに来たらぜひ利用したい
Menginap 2 malam pada bulan Desember 2019
Tanggapan dari Rinradee pada tanggal 18 Des 2019
Thank you for staying with us and for your kind review. We are delighted to note that you had a pleasant experience on that your stay with us; and appreciate your valuable feedback. Thank you once again for your review, we are looking forward to welcoming you on your next stay with us. with kindest regards, Rinradee Siriworatin,

8/10 Bagus

Traveler terverifikasi

Bepergian bersama teman
Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, kondisi & fasilitas properti
This is a beautiful hotel. It is quiet with comfortable beds. We got two free bottles of water (can't drink the tap water), for a seven day stay. After that, there is a charge for every bottle of water. Also, we received a 1 inch by 1 inch square of soap for our entire stay. The hotel is beautiful but these small inconsistancies are grating
Menginap 4 malam pada bulan Desember 2019
Tanggapan dari Rinradee pada tanggal 16 Des 2019
Thank you for staying with us and for your kind review and recommendation.

6/10 Cukup Baik

Daniel, Montréal

Disukai: Kebersihan
Tidak Disukai: Fasilitas, kondisi & fasilitas properti
L'accueil de la propriétaire bienveillant, la localisation assez loin des BONS restaurants, le service de taxi qui facture 50 bath en plus du prix de base 150 bath ( participation remise à l'hôtel pour avoir commander un taxi, du jamais vu. Une cafetière avec 2 capsules dont on charge 50 bath en consommant un café...qui plus es il n'est pas mentionné par un avis devant ou près de la cafetière...Hum !
Menginap 4 malam pada bulan Desember 2019
Tanggapan dari Rinradee pada tanggal 12 Des 2019
Dear Mr. Daniel Ramirez thanks for sharing your feedback. We’re sorry your experience didn’t match your expectations, However We are looking into this issue and hope to resolve it promptly and accurately.

4/10 Buruk

Ernst

Menginap 3 malam pada bulan November 2019

4/10 Buruk

Khoo, Singapore

Bepergian bersama teman
Tidak Disukai: Fasilitas, kondisi & fasilitas properti
The rustic feel of the property may attract some people. The property is old. The balcony door needs to be locked by clicking the lock at a certain angle. The toilet shower door cannot be closed properly. The worse experience was the TV was not functioning properly. We cannot hear the sound and they could not get it rectified. The ambience was quite good and peaceful.
Menginap 1 malam pada bulan November 2019
Tanggapan dari Rinradee pada tanggal 4 Des 2019
Thanks for sharing your feedback. We’re sorry your experience didn’t match your expectations. It was an uncommon instance and we’ll do better.

10/10 Sangat Bagus

Carmen

Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, kondisi & fasilitas properti, kenyamanan kamar
Muy buena estancia
Ubicación muy buena, habitación espléndida, baño recién reformado, buen desayuno (no es buffet), y personal muy amable
Menginap 1 malam pada bulan November 2019
Tanggapan dari Rinradee. pada tanggal 27 Nov 2019
Thank you for staying with us and for your kind review and recommendation.

8/10 Bagus

Traveler terverifikasi

Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, fasilitas, kondisi & fasilitas properti
Menginap 2 malam pada bulan November 2019
Tanggapan dari rinradee pada tanggal 27 Nov 2019
Thank you for staying with us.

10/10 Sangat Bagus

Traveler terverifikasi

Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, fasilitas, kondisi & fasilitas properti
Freundliches Personal, gutes Zimmer, nichts auszusetzen.
Menginap 1 malam pada bulan November 2019
Tanggapan dari rinradee pada tanggal 27 Nov 2019
Thank you for staying with us and for your kind review and recommendation.

10/10 Sangat Bagus

Jerry

Bepergian dalam rombongan
Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, fasilitas, kondisi & fasilitas properti
the proper is very quiet, it is pretty close to the city center and lots of good food.
Menginap 2 malam pada bulan November 2019
Tanggapan dari Rinradee pada tanggal 13 Nov 2019
Thank you for staying with us and for your kind review and recommendation.

10/10 Sangat Bagus

Traveler terverifikasi

Bepergian bersama keluarga
Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, kondisi & fasilitas properti, kenyamanan kamar
Lovely little place. Friendly and very helpful. Love the bicycles!
Menginap 2 malam pada bulan November 2019
Tanggapan dari Rinradee pada tanggal 13 Nov 2019
Thank you for staying with us and for your kind review and recommendation.

10/10 Sangat Bagus

Myungsun

Bepergian dalam rombongan
Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, kondisi & fasilitas properti, kenyamanan kamar
The Best Hotel in Chiang Mai
자전거 대여 꼭 하십시오. 차비도 아끼고 좋은 구경도 많이 할 수 있어요! 모든 직원들 정말 친절하시고, 위치도 훌륭합니다. 완전 강추 호텔! Accessible located at the center of Old City, hospitality that all staff showed during our stay, the best breakfast serving ever, bike & umbrella rental, good facilities, I cant even count how many merits the hotel has to welcome guests
Menginap 4 malam pada bulan November 2019
Tanggapan dari rinradee pada tanggal 27 Nov 2019
Thank you for staying with us and for your kind review and recommendation.

4/10 Buruk

Traveler terverifikasi

Disukai: Kebersihan, kondisi & fasilitas properti
Tidak Disukai: Staf & layanan
-gemütliche Betten -Klimaanlage zu kalt -Personal sprach schlechtes Englisch -Rezeption war nicht immer besetzt
Menginap 4 malam pada bulan Oktober 2019
Tanggapan dari Rinradee pada tanggal 4 Nov 2019
Please accept my sincere apologies for failing to take care of the issue, I have already taken all the necessary measures to ensure that this does not happen again in the future. Thank you for bringing this matter to my attention. Once again, please accept our apologises for any inconvenience caused. Yours sincerely, Rinrade Siriworatin

10/10 Sangat Bagus

Traveler terverifikasi

Bepergian bersama teman, Traveler bisnis
Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, fasilitas, kondisi & fasilitas properti
The whole design and beauty of the place. The FANTASTIC hospitality and super-friendly service. This was really exceptional.
Menginap 2 malam pada bulan Oktober 2019
Tanggapan dari Rinradee. pada tanggal 22 Okt 2019
Thank you for staying with us and for your kind review and recommendation.

10/10 Sangat Bagus

Minka

Disukai: Kebersihan, staf & layanan, kondisi & fasilitas properti, kenyamanan kamar
Menginap 2 malam pada bulan September 2019
Tanggapan dari Rinradee pada tanggal 2 Okt 2019
Thank you for staying with us and for your kind review and recommendation.