City Island hotel guide. onefinestay hotel in City Island, New York

"Housekeeping kept entering the room while we were sleeping in (8:00 am)"

"The property was nice, and the staff was friendly, I was however charged $41.00 for a breakfast that was supposed to be covered by a credit with the hotel and did not find out I was charged for it until it showed up on my bank statement"

"My room, and all public areas were absolutely pristine. My room was gorgeous, spare, fresh. However, it received direct afternoon sun on a warm day. The air conditioning was not working, so it got uncomfortably warm in my room. The rooftop restaurant advertised is no longer open. However, this was an extremely good value and I would stay here again in a heartbeat, "

"I had an absolutely terrible experience at The New Yorker Hotel. After my stay, I was hit with a $500 "smoking fee" despite the fact that I do not smoke and did not smoke in the room. This is a blatant cash grab and a complete lack of integrity on the hotel's part. When I tried to resolve this on-site, the lack of professionalism was staggering. I requested to speak with a manager and was simply handed a business card. I have reached out multiple times to the contact provided, but they have completely ignored my messages. I also asked for a manual check (instead of automated sensor) to check for smoke and was denied. Attempting to dispute the charge has been a nightmare because of their refusal to communicate. Warning to future travelers: Stay elsewhere. There are plenty of hotels in New York that won't slap you with fraudulent fees and then hide behind a non-responsive management team. This was a dishonest and stressful experience from start to finish."

"Room was clean and staff were friendly and helpful. I wish the room had a coffee maker or hotpot. "

"Staff is good but one of the guy is very rude.never give us right answers,tell us wrong rate or extra "

"Housekeeping was very good. My room was cleaned, n given with clean towels everyday. "

"Good."

"The bathroom shower in room 914 was clogged. All other amenities were up to par."