Find hotels in Highland Lake, NY from Rp1.634.913

"For a country inn it's very nice! Clean and comfortable beds. I was very impressed 👏 And the staff is top notch. The breakfast was simple but plentiful and my kids enjoyed it."

"the stay was great and the food was awesome."

"Nice staff and clean room"

"Amazing property! So beautiful I loved the vintage decor!"

"Nice place, clean, quiet, nice staff."

"Perfect trip for children."

"Nice, relaxing, comfortable place staff was super helpful Breakfast was good thanks!"

"The room was clean, the staff was helpful, and the restaurant was five star."

"Perfectly located near the tri-state border, this was a great place to stay while exploring the Delaware River Gap and visiting nearby restaurants and breweries. Owners were helpful and the room was comfortable and well-maintained. Would stay again in the area."

"Very clean and staff helpful "

"Property was a perfect location for us! Staff was super nice, Clean room!!!"

"Breakfast was awesome, and the staff very friendly especially Sam "

"It's a great stay!"

"Great Stay. Bed was comfortable and very clean. I would recommend a stay here"

"Spent one night on a 3 week motorcycle trip Nice people own this and professional front desk staff. Will stay again when in the area"

"Rooms and common areas need updating. Refrigerator in room was extremely loud. Pillows were terrible. Everything was very clean though and staff was helpful."

"I have been around the Lake Wally/Hawley + area for 40yrs (first owning a small summer place on the lake & as a local camp nurse for 20yrs), I always wanted to stay at Settlers--dined there many times--visited the gift shop, even looked into the rooms--finally got the chance--Wonder/Beautiful/Tranquil/Unique!!!"