A town with autumn foliage, a river, and a church with a tall steeple.

Cottages in Cayuga County

Compare and save
  • Change your mind

    Book hotels with free cancellation
  • Treat yourself

    Sign in to save 10% or more on thousands of hotels
  • Be picky

    Search almost a million properties worldwide

Check prices for these dates

In two weeks
In two months
In three months
In four months

Our top choices for Cayuga County cottages

1. Walkable Sodus Point Retreat < 1 Mi to Lake

Walkable Sodus Point Retreat < 1 Mi to Lake
3.0 star property
Sodus Point
10.0 out of 10, Exceptional, (1 review)
"Upon arrival at the home it presented just as depicted in the pictures!! Stayed with my two children and they LOVED it as much as me. The property felt serene, cozy, and comfortable. Very roomy and warm. Whenever I communicated with owner, she was very responsive. Will definitely be coming back!! Extremely happy with the accommodations. Thank you again for sharing and opening your home with us!! "
United States
Aida
Walkable Sodus Point Retreat < 1 Mi to Lake

2. 2 Mi to Syracuse University: Quiet Family Home

2 Mi to Syracuse University: Quiet Family Home
3.0 star property
Eastside
10.0 out of 10, Exceptional, (1 review)
2 Mi to Syracuse University: Quiet Family Home

3. Unique Finger Lakes Converted Horse Barn w/ Patio!

Unique Finger Lakes Converted Horse Barn w/ Patio!
3.0 star property
Geneva
10.0 out of 10, Exceptional, (1 review)
"Everything about this place was exquisite! Our hosts were fantastic! It was such a fabulous place to stay with our doggies! 35 acres to eun and play! The horses & donkey were fun ! The accommodations were clean, comfortable, and uniquely charming! I cant wait to stay again "
United States
Audrey
Unique Finger Lakes Converted Horse Barn w/ Patio!

4. Cozy New York Farmhouse w/ Porch, Grill & Fire Pit

Cozy New York Farmhouse w/ Porch, Grill & Fire Pit
2.0 star property
Geneva
10.0 out of 10, Exceptional, (1 review)
Cozy New York Farmhouse w/ Porch, Grill & Fire Pit

5. Lakefront 4BR w/ Stunning Views, Dock & Porch

Lakefront 4BR w/ Stunning Views, Dock & Porch
3.0 star property
Auburn
10.0 out of 10, Exceptional, (1 review)
"If I'm in the area, I'll definitely return to this house!"
United States
Nadiya
Lakefront 4BR w/ Stunning Views, Dock & Porch

6. Charming Burdett Home With Grill, Gazebo + Yard

Charming Burdett Home With Grill, Gazebo + Yard
3.0 star property
Burdett
2.0 out of 10, (1 review)
"The property was extremely outdated and infested with bugs all over the windows and few crawlers on the floor. The AC was useless, barely cooling the room in the sweltering summer heat. The property manager was awful, telling us to find another hotel at our own expense when the power went out, leaving us without electricity, water, or working toilets. Do not stay here—if the power goes out, you're on your own with no backup generator, no support, and no basic amenities. Not recommended."
United States
Loren
Charming Burdett Home With Grill, Gazebo + Yard

7. Rural Oswego Cottage on 50-acre Orchard & Farm!

Rural Oswego Cottage on 50-acre Orchard & Farm!
3.0 star property
Oswego
10.0 out of 10, Exceptional, (1 review)
"Very easy rental. Our host was available as needed, but we were free to come and go as we pleased. It’s out a ways from town, which for us was ideal. Highly recommend this property."
United States
David
Rural Oswego Cottage on 50-acre Orchard & Farm!

8. Home w/ Private Dock on Cayuta Lake!

Home w/ Private Dock on Cayuta Lake!
3.0 star property
Alpine
8.0 out of 10, Very good, (3 reviews)
"A gem on a quiet lake. Near vineyards and countless waterfalls."
United States
christine
Home w/ Private Dock on Cayuta Lake!

9. Spacious Finger Lakes Home w/ Mountain Views

Spacious Finger Lakes Home w/ Mountain Views
3.0 star property
Dryden
Spacious Finger Lakes Home w/ Mountain Views

10. Iconic Finger Lakes Home Near Taughannock Falls

Iconic Finger Lakes Home Near Taughannock Falls
3.0 star property
Downtown Trumansburg
Iconic Finger Lakes Home Near Taughannock Falls

11. Finger Lakes Retreat w/ Sunroom, Fire Pit & Bbq!

Finger Lakes Retreat w/ Sunroom, Fire Pit & Bbq!
3.0 star property
Himrod
Finger Lakes Retreat w/ Sunroom, Fire Pit & Bbq!

12. Finger Lakes Farm Retreat: Walk to Wineries!

Finger Lakes Farm Retreat: Walk to Wineries!
3.0 star property
Hector
Finger Lakes Farm Retreat: Walk to Wineries!

13. Waterfront Seneca Lake House: Fire Pit + Boat Dock

Waterfront Seneca Lake House: Fire Pit + Boat Dock
3.0 star property
Geneva
Waterfront Seneca Lake House: Fire Pit + Boat Dock

14. Geneva Vacation Rental w/ Vineyard & Lake Views!

Geneva Vacation Rental w/ Vineyard & Lake Views!
3.0 star property
Geneva
Geneva Vacation Rental w/ Vineyard & Lake Views!

15. Fishing Pond & Spacious Yard: Quiet Home in Sodus!

Fishing Pond & Spacious Yard: Quiet Home in Sodus!
3.0 star property
Sodus
8.8 out of 10, Excellent, (3 reviews)
"The property was dirty when we arrived making our stay a little uncomfortable. It was sufficient for what we used it for, but that was only because we were out touring the surrounding area for most of the day and only stayed at the home to sleep. The property has great potential, but we would recommend more effort into cleaning up the inside and yard."
United States
Jake
Fishing Pond & Spacious Yard: Quiet Home in Sodus!

16. Peaceful Lakefront Getaway On Cayuga Lake 4 Bedroom Cottage

Peaceful Lakefront Getaway On Cayuga Lake 4 Bedroom Cottage
3.0 star property
Aurora
Peaceful Lakefront Getaway On Cayuga Lake 4 Bedroom Cottage

17. Bayfront Red Creek Vacation Rental w/ Boat Dock!

Bayfront Red Creek Vacation Rental w/ Boat Dock!
3.0 star property
Red Creek
Bayfront Red Creek Vacation Rental w/ Boat Dock!

18. Spacious Home by Finger Lakes & Watkins Glen!

Spacious Home by Finger Lakes & Watkins Glen!
3.0 star property
Burdett
8.0 out of 10, Very good, (1 review)
"Rented the place for two days trip with 4 other friends. It’s was very nice to be there. Downstairs bedroom is dirty the carpet needs to be changed and also the windows are dirty. Overall excellent job though out the house we were very comfortable. I will definitely recommend it. "
United States
Shehla
Spacious Home by Finger Lakes & Watkins Glen!

19. Serene Lodi Escape w/ Deck: Boat, Hike & Sip!

Serene Lodi Escape w/ Deck: Boat, Hike & Sip!
3.0 star property
Lodi
9.0 out of 10, Wonderful, (2 reviews)
"The place was really great. It was homey and open. It was easy to get around and the dogs loved it. It was warm and the views were really spectacular. We're thinking of renting again in the summer. The owner was quick to address any questions we had and was really sweet and helpful."
United States
Glenn
Serene Lodi Escape w/ Deck: Boat, Hike & Sip!

20. Cayuga Lake , hot Tub, Private Dock

Cayuga Lake , hot Tub, Private Dock
3.0 star property
Cayuga
Cayuga Lake , hot Tub, Private Dock
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.
Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in

Top Cayuga County Hotel Reviews

Find out more about Cayuga County

Cayuga County Cottages information

Number of reviews
12
Accommodation
111 Cottages
Lowest Price
Highest Price