Search Hotels Near Key Cay, Great Harbour

"Staff was fantastic and accommodating. "

"We only stayed one night before getting on a sailboat charter but we really enjoyed our time at Nanny Cay and would definitely come again. We ate dinner at pig legs right at the ocean and had breakfast the next morning at Omar‘s. Both were excellent."

"Trip was amazing. This is a small resort that has incredible rooms, restaurants, and a private beach. The staff was attentive, friendly, and always ready to help. The manager, Andrea, was very helpful and always was ready to do whatever we needed to make our stay great. The main restaurant had amazing food and outstanding service. The beachfront restaurant was a little more casual but food and service was great as well. Eating breakfast on the beach was relaxing. Carlos at the bar was friendly and good with the drinks. The resort is remote and not in a busy area, while this is wonderfully relaxing it does mean that there is very little within walking distance. There are a couple of restaurants within walking distance, if you need to go to the store or to another restaurant you'll need a taxi. The hotel is always glad to help you book one and the cab drivers were all fun and happy to talk about the island. If you're looking for a relaxing trip to the beach, with beautiful views, amazing staff, away from crowds, and top tier food you won't go wrong with the Sugar Mill. "

"Clean. Friendly staff. "

"Everything was too notch from the pre-stay contact by the staff on airport transfers, to the room, coordination of activities and taxis to great food and beach bar. Loved the stay and can’t say enough good things. Thanks. "

"Excellent experience! Quick and easy check in, clean, comfortable accommodation with everything you need to prepare meals. Wonderful view and great restaurant onsite. Tia, the property manager was so kind and accommodating. "

"Very corteous staff, well maintained villas with ample parking. Very close to nice beaches and restaurants."

"The room property were very clean. The staff were helpful and nice. The property and room are charming. Fresh little flowers on the bed and table. You will not mistake this for a corporate hotel and that is a good thing! If you have mobility issues this is probably not the place for you as the drive up/walk is steep. We would stay there again."

"Lovely staff. Fabulous location! I appreciated having some basic supplies in the kitchen (tea, coffee, sugar, salt) and water in the refrigerator. "