8/10 Bagus
Nathan
Bepergian bersama teman
8 Feb 2026
Disukai: Kebersihan, fasilitas, kondisi & fasilitas properti
We stayed at Captain Pips about 5 years ago on our first trip to the Keys. We hadn't stayed in Marathon since then and decided to revisit and stay here again.
Pros:
-Well stocked with kitchen supplies
-Great location and short drives to beaches and stores
-On-site store for little items, snacks, etc.
Cons
-We stayed on a lower level this time. There is a THIN door inside that connects to the room on the other side. You can hear everything - and I mean everything - that your neighbors are doing. There are no private conversations. Thankfully we didn't have to deal with people carrying on late into the night.
-Our trip was during the big cold snap. The bedroom ac/heat unit worked fine the first 2 nights. Third day it stopped working completely. Called the maintenance number, left a message, never got a response. Went the rest of the stay without ever being contacted or fixed. Luckily there was enough extra linens to stay warm through the nights.
-"Ocean" view is meh as you're going to mostly be looking at docked boats.
I'd rate it at 3-1/2 stars if I could. There's something that doesn't feel as welcoming as other places we've stayed at in the Keys, and we've stayed at a lot of different places. Here you feel more like a number and not a guest. We had fond memories of our first visit, but the cons were enough that we won't stay here again.
Nathan
Menginap 4 malam pada bulan Januari 2026
