Search Hotels in Montclair Colony, Shelter Island

"My husband and I stayed two nights. There was a large wedding party in the facility as well. Everyone- guests and staff- was very nice, but the reception took over the whole lobby the afternoon of the wedding and we had to literally wade through hundreds of people drinking, laughing and talking just to get from the only elevator to the exit (or the restaurant or the pool or anywhere else). For anyone but wedding guests, it was quite overwhelming. It seems the wedding business is a big part of the business there, but it should not impede other guests's right to, and expectation of, a relaxing stay."

"Fantastic!"

"Good location"

"Large King bedroom. Nice bathroom. Great snacks."

"Stayed for a quick getaway after a play at the Suffolk Theatre! Staff was kind and helpful. Room was clean and spacious. Town is walkable. Many restaurants to choose from . Will add The Preston House to our getaway list !"

"Lovely hotel. Very clean, very friendly staff, great water pressure. Breakfast was continental... Fruit, cereal, yogurt, muffins. Fresh coffee. Overall nice experience. "

"The property was just as described and we couldn't have been more pleasantly surprised when we arrived after the long trek thru what seemed like nothingness between NYC and Southampton. At 1st glance we were a bit skeptical, but upon entry found the property ti be a hidden gem. We even extended our stay to explore more of the fabulous Hamptons. "

"My girlfriend and I stayed in April and it was amazing stay. Rooms are outstanding, one of the best rooms we ever stayed, and location was stunning. Beautiful marina, great waterfront views from the property. It was so quiet and relaxing. We went to Greenport for dinners. 10$ Breakfast cards were provided by hotel for Stone Street eatery and it was nice delicious meal. My girlfriend is from Milan, Italy and this was her first time in North Fork and she absolutely loved it thanks to The Shoals. "

"Great "