Search Beach Resorts & Hotels in Shelter Island

"Clean and quality hotel ***. Friendly and helpful staff."

"Very clean bare-bones hotel in a quiet location. Large rooms. Nice breakfast place across the road and a short drive to more services and stores. Helpful staff. Only criticism -- and it's an important one -- is that there were no friction strips or other kind of safety on the bathtub, so it was unexpectedly slippery."

"Absolutely amazing! Staff was wonderful, views are breathtaking, the bathe house is worth the extra splurge to stay at this property. Few things, bring a bottle opener if you think you will need it. There was a small ants problem in the bathroom and I wish they had hooks in the bathroom but otherwise, I would definitely go back."

"Beautiful place to stay on a special getaway"

"Unhinged wacko"

"We were charged an additional “Resort Fee” upon check in of $76 per room. We questioned it because it was for use of the pool, towels, and beach chairs. However the pool was closed! There were no chairs, not even on the deck outside our room. We asked to speak to the manager about waiving the fee, she was never there nor has she returned the three phone messages I have left with the staff. Very disappointed. I have stayed here before but will not again."

"Incredible staff"

"The breakfast was fresh and delicious!"

"The rooms were clean. The bathroom had a pocket door for the toilet area that did not close properly and the lock did not work. The shower was outside the toilet area, but there was no door only a curtain."