Shelter Island hotel guide. Wyndham Hotels hotel in Shelter Island, New York

"We’ve stayed at this hotel before in the winter and it was a great. This time we were staying there and there was no heat. All they had was a small space heater for the room. Fortunately the front desk gave us a refund and we went to another hotel but just know there isn’t heat in the rooms in the winter except a space heater."

"Really liked the property and would have been fun in the summer. Bed was comfy and there was a nice steamer. My only complaint is just how small the bathroom was. Other rooms may have larger ones, but it was tiny and that could be an issue for some."

"Great views from the restaurant and bar area. Staff were very friendly and attentive. Will stay here again."

"I was skeptical at first since many comments are negative. As a woman of color, my experience was fantastic. The staff was lovely. I booked the ocean view room which was to my expectations. Overall 10/10 will return."

"The breakfast was delicious, the rooms were nice, and the bar was perfect. In all of my travels I think the staff at this hotel might be the nicest, most accommodating people I’ve ever met. They truly made our stay wonderful. Olga and the other front desk staff were amazing. "

"Beautiful hotel facing the harbor with courteous service and staff. "

"It was a good experience in general, definitely recommend and I would go back if I need to"

"Clean and quality hotel ***. Friendly and helpful staff."

"The staff were great and the rooms were in greay shape and very comfortable. The location is close to many restaurants. "