Hotel Independent di Pulau Caldey

"Food is excellent and beds are very comfy. It's old-fashioned in that it's a conversion of an older building, so windows are single-glazed and the doors open with actual keys. But the rooms have everything you'd expect from a professionally run establishment. Staff are all friendly and professional though you sometimes have to seek them out – hardly surprising as there are only six rooms so they can't have someone permanently on duty."

"Plenty of free parking The service from staff from checking in to checking out was superb. The breakfast was very good. Our room was large enough for our needs and clean with very comfortable bed. Bar open in evening and prices on par with pubs."