Fire Island hotel guide. Hilton Hotels hotel in Fire Island, New York

"Was very surprised that hotels.com rated this an 8.0. It was far from an 8.0. First we were put in a room that the bed was not made. Second room was in tact but had a whole in the room ceiling, and no drain plug in the sink. To say something positive I could say they did have clean towels and they did honor our wishes to be on the ground floor. The glass in casement upon entering the hotel lobby gave me the impression that this area is not so safe so one night was all I could take. Will be watching more closely the rates on hotels.com from now on."

"Very clean plenty of space and very quiet hotel."

"A very nice and welcoming hotel Friendly staff and spacious rooms Breakfast was very good"

"The room was beautiful and spacious. Comfortable bed. The front desk staff was friendly and helpful. Highly recommend this hotel!"

"The hotel was rundown, but it looked like they might be making improvements in the future."

"Very comfortable and friendly staff"

"Worst hotel I’ve ever stayed at in my life"

"Good, calm and quiet place. Very good location! Staff were helpful and fast!"

"Decent motel"