Search Hotels in Hay Beach, Shelter Island

Start date: Check-in selected.
To Date
End date: Check-out

  • Change your mind

    Book hotels with free cancellation

  • Treat yourself

    Sign in to save 10% or more on thousands of hotels
    Sign in

  • Be picky

    Search almost a million properties worldwide

Check prices for these dates

Tonight
31 Dec - 1 Jan
Tomorrow
1 Jan - 2 Jan
This weekend
2 Jan - 4 Jan
Next weekend
9 Jan - 11 Jan

Filter by

Guest rating
Guest rating
Star rating

Our top choices for Hay Beach hotels

Garden
The Huntting Inn

The Huntting Inn

The Huntting Inn
3.5 star property
19.5 km from Hay Beach
9.0 out of 10, Wonderful, (104)
"Staff and management was very welcoming!"
United States
Sanailer
The price is Rp6.414.908
Rp7.496.637 total
includes taxes & fees
14 Jan - 15 Jan 2026
The Huntting Inn
Exterior
American Beech Hotel

American Beech Hotel

American Beech Hotel
3.5 star property
2.5 km from Hay Beach
8.8 out of 10, Excellent, (195)
"The property was clean beautiful and pleasant. Loved the trendy decor."
United States
Jennifer
The price is Rp4.175.979
Rp5.441.854 total
includes taxes & fees
2 Jan - 3 Jan 2026
American Beech Hotel
Garden
The 1770 House Restaurant & Inn

The 1770 House Restaurant & Inn

The 1770 House Restaurant & Inn
4.0 star property
19.5 km from Hay Beach
9.8 out of 10, Exceptional, (161)
"The staff was incredibly genuine and the property felt intimate and comfortable."
United States
Aniya
The price is Rp4.205.328
Rp5.748.931 total
includes taxes & fees
4 Jan - 5 Jan 2026
The 1770 House Restaurant & Inn
Beach nearby, white sand, sun-loungers, beach umbrellas
The Roundtree, Amagansett

The Roundtree, Amagansett

The Roundtree, Amagansett
4.5 star property
20.9 km from Hay Beach
10.0 out of 10, Exceptional, (91)
"Located right in the center of town, the grounds on this property are wonderful with clean and comfortable suites. The staff are engaging and sweet. And the late night cookies are a sweet touch."
United States
adam
The price is Rp9.968.267
Rp11.958.121 total
includes taxes & fees
1 Jan - 2 Jan 2026
The Roundtree, Amagansett
One Bedroom Harbor View Terrace Suite | View from room
The Harbor Front Inn

The Harbor Front Inn

The Harbor Front Inn
3.5 star property
2.7 km from Hay Beach
8.8 out of 10, Excellent, (555)
"Room and staff were amazing. "
United States
Manuel
The price is Rp2.346.598
Rp3.159.969 total
includes taxes & fees
14 Jan - 15 Jan 2026
The Harbor Front Inn
Exterior
Journey East Hampton

Journey East Hampton

Journey East Hampton
4.0 star property
20.4 km from Hay Beach
9.0 out of 10, Wonderful, (160)
"We were able to access many beaches with the beach pass that came with the stay. That was the main reason we wanted to stay there. The rooms were very nice, spacious and comfortable. "
United States
Sarah
Journey East Hampton
Garden Suite King | Premium bedding, down duvets, individually decorated
The Shoals Suites and Slips

The Shoals Suites and Slips

The Shoals Suites and Slips
3.5 star property
6.7 km from Hay Beach
9.4 out of 10, Exceptional, (232)
"Great stay, will definitely go again"
United States
ANTONIO J
The price is Rp3.110.853
Rp3.554.149 total
includes taxes & fees
1 Jan - 2 Jan 2026
The Shoals Suites and Slips
Outdoor pool
Topping Rose House

Topping Rose House

Topping Rose House
4.5 star property
18.2 km from Hay Beach
9.2 out of 10, Wonderful, (138)
"Our second home :)"
United States
olivia
The price is Rp8.980.870
Rp10.319.343 total
includes taxes & fees
1 Jan - 2 Jan 2026
Topping Rose House
Breakfast and dinner served
Copper Beech Inn

Copper Beech Inn

Copper Beech Inn
4.0 star property
28.8 km from Hay Beach
8.6 out of 10, Excellent, (506)
"Very nice property. Very clean. Staff was very nice - very good breakfast. "
United States
Marilyn
The price is Rp4.679.109
Rp5.380.975 total
includes taxes & fees
1 Jan - 2 Jan 2026
Copper Beech Inn
Property grounds
Inn at Harbor Hill Marina

Inn at Harbor Hill Marina

Inn at Harbor Hill Marina
3.5 star property
27.9 km from Hay Beach
9.4 out of 10, Exceptional, (1001)
"Clean great staff great breakfast quiet guests beautiful scenery 10/10"
United States
Trey
The price is Rp2.666.589
Rp3.066.577 total
includes taxes & fees
1 Jan - 2 Jan 2026
Inn at Harbor Hill Marina
Garden
The Maidstone

The Maidstone

The Maidstone
4.0 star property
19.7 km from Hay Beach
8.0 out of 10, Very good, (150)
"We had a wonderful stay "
United States
Sabrina
The price is Rp4.694.764
Rp5.363.767 total
includes taxes & fees
4 Jan - 5 Jan 2026
The Maidstone
Beach bar
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows

Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows

Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows
4.0 star property
3.9 km from Hay Beach
9.8 out of 10, Exceptional, (142)
"Great get away "
United States
Charles
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows
Exterior
The Sagaponack

The Sagaponack

The Sagaponack
3.0 star property
18.1 km from Hay Beach
8.8 out of 10, Excellent, (218)
"Clean & amenities, staff friendly Thank you "
United States
Archil
The price is Rp2.701.808
Rp3.757.447 total
includes taxes & fees
1 Jan - 2 Jan 2026
The Sagaponack
View from property
House on Chase Creek

House on Chase Creek

House on Chase Creek
2.5 star property
2.8 km from Hay Beach
9.4 out of 10, Exceptional, (79)
" This was my husband and my first time visiting Shelter Island and I feel lucky that my stay was at the House of ChaseCreek. Bill was excellent in helping us navigate our stay on the Island which made for an enjoyable experience. The house was charming , very clean , and had easy access to the town restaurant s, and Ferry. Highly recommend ! "
United States
Maureen
The price is Rp1.746.364
Rp1.995.414 total
includes taxes & fees
6 Jan - 7 Jan 2026
House on Chase Creek
Outdoor pool
The Atlantic Hotel

The Atlantic Hotel

The Atlantic Hotel
2.5 star property
25 km from Hay Beach
7.2 out of 10, Good, (975)
"Great hotel for a quick stay - very friendly staff"
United States
Dianne
The Atlantic Hotel
Terrace/patio
The Bentley Hotel Southampton

The Bentley Hotel Southampton

The Bentley Hotel Southampton
2.0 star property
25.5 km from Hay Beach
9.6 out of 10, Exceptional, (415)
"Adorable boutique hotel with charming unique touches. "
United States
Mary
The price is Rp2.062.833
Rp2.373.557 total
includes taxes & fees
22 Jan - 23 Jan 2026
The Bentley Hotel Southampton
Terrace/patio
Westbrook Inn B&B

Westbrook Inn B&B

Westbrook Inn B&B
3.0 star property
23 km from Hay Beach
9.8 out of 10, Exceptional, (178)
"Our stay was amazing! All the staff were so accommodating and kind. The inn has a rustic charm and was so festive for the holidays! Rooms are a good size, clean, and have everything you need. The breakfast was delicious and they even had free tea/coffee/cookies for all guests to enjoy :) "
United States
Chewon
The price is Rp3.797.625
Rp4.215.364 total
includes taxes & fees
4 Jan - 5 Jan 2026
Westbrook Inn B&B
Exterior
Madison Beach Hotel

Madison Beach Hotel

Madison Beach Hotel
4.0 star property
30 km from Hay Beach
9.4 out of 10, Exceptional, (342)
"Wonderful staff"
United States
Rebecca
The price is Rp4.997.758
Rp5.747.422 total
includes taxes & fees
1 Jan - 2 Jan 2026
Madison Beach Hotel
Property entrance
The Menhaden

The Menhaden

The Menhaden
3.5 star property
2.7 km from Hay Beach
9.6 out of 10, Exceptional, (173)
"Wonderful stay in a quaint hotel..The small town was amazing and had such cozy welcoming atmosphere! "
United States
Cory
The price is Rp4.511.399
Rp5.825.239 total
includes taxes & fees
8 Jan - 9 Jan 2026
The Menhaden
Exterior
The Rams Head Inn

The Rams Head Inn

The Rams Head Inn
4.0 star property
3.7 km from Hay Beach
7.6 out of 10, Good, (18)
"Beautiful views and lovely service "
United States
Lana
The Rams Head Inn
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.
View all properties

Where to stay in Hay Beach

Find the best Hay Beach areas for the activities you enjoy most.

Silver Beach

While Silver Beach may not have many sights to explore, venturing just a little farther will lead you to top things to see and do like Sunset Beach and Crescent Beach.

Menantic Creek

While there might not be top attractions in Menantic Creek, you can explore the larger area and discover places like Sunset Beach and Shelter Island Whale's Tail.

Coecles Harbor

While Coecles Harbor isn't home to many top sights, Shelter Island Whale's Tail and Gardiner's Bay Country Club are some notable places to visit nearby.

Shorewood

While Shorewood may not have many sights to explore, venturing just a little farther will lead you to top things to see and do like Mashomack Preserve and Shelter Island Historical Society.

Montclair Colony

If you're looking for some top things to see and do in Montclair Colony and surrounding area, you can visit Sunset Beach and Shelter Island Historical Society.

Top Hay Beach Hotel Reviews

The Harbor Front Inn

The Harbor Front Inn

10/10 Excellent
"Great check in experience. Very nice room"
Christopher 2-night trip
Posted 5 days ago
The Harbor Front Inn

Frequently asked questions

What is Hay Beach like?
Travellers to the Hay Beach neighbourhood in Shelter Island will be sure to enjoy their stay. Consider a visit to Menhadden Lane Beach as part of your Hay Beach travel plans.
How many hotels will I find in the Hay Beach area?
When you want to put your feet up after a day of exploring the sights in Shelter Island, you can choose from 12 Expedia hotels and other accommodation options in Hay Beach.
If I need to cancel my hotel reservation in Hay Beach, will I receive a refund?
Yes! You'll find that most room reservations are fully refundable if you cancel prior to the accommodation's cancellation deadline, which is usually within 24-48 hours of check in. If your reservation is non-refundable, you might still have the option to cancel and receive a refund within a 24-hour period of booking. Enter your dates, click on "Search", then use the "fully refundable" filter to view the best deals available in Hay Beach.
What are the top things to see and do in Hay Beach?
Menhadden Lane Beach is an attraction you might want to check out while you're in Hay Beach. When you're sightseeing in Shelter Island, Gardiner's Bay Country Club and Norman E. Klipp Marine Park are also worth a stop.

Explore a world of travel with Expedia