- Change your mindBook hotels with free cancellation
- Be pickySearch almost a million properties worldwide
Check prices for these dates
Top Randall's Island Hotel Reviews




Hard Rock Hotel New York - Partner of ALL Accor
Hard Rock Hotel New York - Partner of ALL AccorManhattan
10/10 Excellent
.
.
Camilla




Hampton Inn Manhattan/Times Square Central
Hampton Inn Manhattan/Times Square CentralManhattan
10/10 Excellent
The hotel itself is clean and centrally located for NYC tourism in Times Sq. the staff are great, breakfast included was a good start to each day and the price we got through Expedia was a bargain. Be warned that there is a migrant shelter directly opposite the hotel which can be intimidating as large groups hang around outside - the hotel have a regular security guard and the NYPD are outside the shelter all the time.
The hotel itself is clean and centrally located for NYC tourism in Times Sq. the staff are great, breakfast included was a good start to each day and the price we got through Expedia was a bargain. Be warned that there is a migrant shelter directly opposite the hotel which can be intimidating as large groups hang around outside - the hotel have a regular security guard and the NYPD are outside the shelter all the time.
John




The Lucerne Hotel
The Lucerne HotelManhattan
10/10 Excellent
Fantastic location as the hotel is close to subway station so can easily get anywhere, but it’s in a more peaceful part of town. There are loads of excellent restaurants and coffee shops around.
Our room (two double beds) was spacious, clean and comfortable.
Staff were friendly and helpful.
I would recommend and would definitely stay again.
Fantastic location as the hotel is close to subway station so can easily get anywhere, but it’s in a more peaceful part of town. There are loads of excellent restaurants and coffee shops around.
Our room (two double beds) was spacious, clean and comfortable.
Staff were friendly and helpful.
I would recommend and would definitely stay again.
Gillian




The Westin New York Grand Central
The Westin New York Grand CentralManhattan
10/10 Excellent
We had a fantastic few days at the Westin. The staff were so helpful. It was central for everything, especially the subway. The bed and pillows were the most comfortable I have ever experienced. I would definitely recommend this hotel.
We had a fantastic few days at the Westin. The staff were so helpful. It was central for everything, especially the subway. The bed and pillows were the most comfortable I have ever experienced. I would definitely recommend this hotel.
Nora Teresa




Hotel Belleclaire Central Park, a Small Luxury Hotel
Hotel Belleclaire Central Park, a Small Luxury HotelManhattan
10/10 Excellent
The hotel has no breakfast available, just a coupon for a coffe shop next door
The hotel has no breakfast available, just a coupon for a coffe shop next door
michael




Hilton Garden Inn New York/West 35th Street
Hilton Garden Inn New York/West 35th StreetManhattan
10/10 Excellent
Great location. Excellent sound proofing from the street and other rooms. Comfortable and clean. Excellent stay all round.
Great location. Excellent sound proofing from the street and other rooms. Comfortable and clean. Excellent stay all round.
Mikaela




Courtyard by Marriott New York Manhattan/Midtown East
Courtyard by Marriott New York Manhattan/Midtown EastManhattan
10/10 Excellent
Great location, friendly staff, nice and tidy rooms… will stay again
Great location, friendly staff, nice and tidy rooms… will stay again
Simon




Arlo Midtown
Arlo MidtownManhattan
10/10 Excellent
My daughter and I had a trip to New York for our big birthdays, hotel was very central close to port authority, walking distance to time square and many other areas. Hotel staff made our visit special for us and are very helpful , friendly , professional and knowledgeable about the surrounding area. I would avoid 9th Avenue at night time as it didn’t feel very safe .
My daughter and I had a trip to New York for our big birthdays, hotel was very central close to port authority, walking distance to time square and many other areas. Hotel staff made our visit special for us and are very helpful , friendly , professional and knowledgeable about the surrounding area. I would avoid 9th Avenue at night time as it didn’t feel very safe .
Edward




Hilton Garden Inn New York Times Square South
Hilton Garden Inn New York Times Square SouthManhattan
10/10 Excellent
I really appreciated this hotel being my base. The staff were phenomenally friendly, welcoming and helpful. That made a big difference to me as this was my first time in NY, on a ten day trip alone. A big adventure. The mattress was firm (very important) AND there were feather pillows. Close to travel and amenities. It’s listed as three star. I see it as four star. Very good value for money.
I really appreciated this hotel being my base. The staff were phenomenally friendly, welcoming and helpful. That made a big difference to me as this was my first time in NY, on a ten day trip alone. A big adventure. The mattress was firm (very important) AND there were feather pillows. Close to travel and amenities. It’s listed as three star. I see it as four star. Very good value for money.
Jonathan




Pod Times Square
Pod Times SquareManhattan
10/10 Excellent
It was just as I expected. It was not noisy at all (being so close to Times Square).
I booked a room with a bunk bed and it was as small as shown in the pictures so definitely as expected.
Stay was comfortable.
It was just as I expected. It was not noisy at all (being so close to Times Square).
I booked a room with a bunk bed and it was as small as shown in the pictures so definitely as expected.
Stay was comfortable.
Gautam




Courtyard New York Manhattan/Times Square West
Courtyard New York Manhattan/Times Square WestManhattan
10/10 Excellent
Great location and great hotel to act as a base for New York.
Great location and great hotel to act as a base for New York.
GARY




The Muse New York
The Muse New YorkManhattan
10/10 Excellent
Good location
Good location
Emma




Hotel Riu Plaza Manhattan Times Square
Hotel Riu Plaza Manhattan Times SquareManhattan
10/10 Excellent
Fantastic hotel and location. Rooms very quiet. Superbly clean. Excellent breakfast. Brilliant to be able to leave suitcases all day and get a shower in the complementary shower rooms after check out. Only slight negative is it took a while to navigate the lifts in a morning with people going to breakfast.
Would definitely recommend.
Fantastic hotel and location. Rooms very quiet. Superbly clean. Excellent breakfast. Brilliant to be able to leave suitcases all day and get a shower in the complementary shower rooms after check out. Only slight negative is it took a while to navigate the lifts in a morning with people going to breakfast.
Would definitely recommend.
Katherine Lucy




Tempo by Hilton New York Times Square
Tempo by Hilton New York Times SquareManhattan
10/10 Excellent
Can't fault the hotel, room was lovely!
Breakfast was great too.
I didn't realise it was in the middle of Time Square! oops! Quite busy outside... Happily stay again, I was over for a work trip.
Can't fault the hotel, room was lovely!
Breakfast was great too.
I didn't realise it was in the middle of Time Square! oops! Quite busy outside... Happily stay again, I was over for a work trip.
Priya




Romer Hell's Kitchen
Romer Hell's KitchenManhattan
10/10 Excellent
Hotel was ideal for its purpose. Close to everything planned for an elderly relative visiting with us.
Hotel was ideal for its purpose. Close to everything planned for an elderly relative visiting with us.
Tracey




Kixby
KixbyManhattan
10/10 Excellent
There is absolutely nothing bad to say about Kixby. The location is as safe as it gets,easy walking distance from Penn Station if you come in by LIRR/Airtrain from JFK(30 mins hassle free way to get into Manhattan) and the subway is 50 yards from the front door.
There are the best selection of bars,restaurants and eateries within minutes of the hotel as well as Maddison Square Garden and the Empire State Building.
All of the staff were friendly,helpful and informative,you get a free water...
There is absolutely nothing bad to say about Kixby. The location is as safe as it gets,easy walking distance from Penn Station if you come in by LIRR/Airtrain from JFK(30 mins hassle free way to get into Manhattan) and the subway is 50 yards from the front door.
There are the best selection of bars,restaurants and eateries within minutes of the hotel as well as Maddison Square Garden and the Empire State Building.
All of the staff were friendly,helpful and informative,you get a free water...
GARY




Hyatt Regency Times Square
Hyatt Regency Times SquareManhattan
10/10 Excellent
Stayed in the king room with Times Square view, it was perfect. Huge comfortable bed, very clean and spacious. As two women it felt very secure and safe, with staff at all entrances and key card needed to access lift and extra lock on the bedroom door, which was something I was looking for.
Stayed in the king room with Times Square view, it was perfect. Huge comfortable bed, very clean and spacious. As two women it felt very secure and safe, with staff at all entrances and key card needed to access lift and extra lock on the bedroom door, which was something I was looking for.
Lisa Marie




Executive Hotel Le Soleil New York
Executive Hotel Le Soleil New YorkManhattan
10/10 Excellent
We arrived a little after 3pm, and had a lovely greeting from staff, but our room wasn’t ready so we had to wait.
We booked and paid through Expedia… an Empire via room with living space. Please note that the hotel does not offer this type of room. None of their Empire View rooms have the separate living room area. The Empire view rooms do give a great view of the Empire State Building but their ‘living room’ is a tiny space with a chaise and a TV. Management were excellent with us and moved us...
We arrived a little after 3pm, and had a lovely greeting from staff, but our room wasn’t ready so we had to wait.
We booked and paid through Expedia… an Empire via room with living space. Please note that the hotel does not offer this type of room. None of their Empire View rooms have the separate living room area. The Empire view rooms do give a great view of the Empire State Building but their ‘living room’ is a tiny space with a chaise and a TV. Management were excellent with us and moved us...
Karon




Club Quarters Hotel Grand Central, New York
Club Quarters Hotel Grand Central, New YorkManhattan
10/10 Excellent
This hotel's location near a major transportation hub offers unparalleled convenience. A charming coffee room provides a relaxing space to unwind. Guests can also enjoy views from the outdoor area. The very comfortable accommodation is great for safety and security. This hotel comes highly recommended for a fab stay.
This hotel's location near a major transportation hub offers unparalleled convenience. A charming coffee room provides a relaxing space to unwind. Guests can also enjoy views from the outdoor area. The very comfortable accommodation is great for safety and security. This hotel comes highly recommended for a fab stay.
George
