Search Hotels Near Sagamore Hill National Historic Site, Oyster Bay

"Fantastic place to stay, staff is wonderful, i used to stay at Jakes 58 , this hotel so much better, my new favorite hotel, will not stay anywhere else!!!"

"I did not end up staying as the place was loud it was late and I needed rest there were people hanging out right outside the room… plus there was blood on the bed lamp… scary to stay there"

"So this is a basic hotel in an expensive town. It wants to be special, but it isn’t. It is honestly a little weird. Here’s my story: Check in: mildly annoyed desk agent would not check me in, spouse name on reservation. Ugh. I booked Expedia so I didn’t think to add myself. So, we are at an impass. But no! There’s an answer! Just call here on your cell, and have her tell us it is ok for you to check in and add yourself to the reservation. Done. Fine. What was the point of that stupid exercise? But, I have permission. Great. Agent then makes a weird production of taking out latex gloves, snapping them on, TO TOUCH MY ID. Ok . Whatever. Hotel is like 1/2 a city block square. I ask: how do I get to my room? Reasonable question. I ask because I see on the way in there is parking all around the hotel. “It’s up the stairs or elevator to floor 2. Follow the signs.” As I walk 5 minutes, I realize I should have driven to the back of the hotel. One of the most bizarre passive aggressive check ins I’ve ever had. Shampoo is a soap bar. Weird Have to ask for hair conditioner (wife’s issue) Weird Breakfast was Ok, but not special. Breakfast area espresso machine was nice. I suspect this is a local event venue, and I’m not local. So Won’t return. "

"Free parking clean rooms"

"Breakfast selection not like it used to be. Not many choices. Hardly any fruit."

"Cery quite place "

"The property was a great location and the staff was very helpful!"

"Decent motel"

"PLEASE DO NOT STAY HERE IF YOU DO NOT ABSOLUTELY HAVE TO! It is gross and engulfed in mold. We were trying to save money but this place it NOT worth the savings. The housekeeping did the best they could, but the building and furniture are complete TRASH. The place looks like it should be condemned and the furniture looks like it was salvaged from the dump. I am not exaggerating. We needed a last-minute reservation for at least 4 consecutive nights when we received news of a relative's death. The airfare and missed work were already going to be a large financial burden, so we tried to save money on the hotel. We thought bringing our own linens and towels would be enough, but we know better now not to trust this sort of place ever again. The shower had good pressure and the hot water didn't run out, and thank goodness for that, because the only reason we stayed was because we were able to purchase bleach at the grocery store right across the street. What makes all of this incredibly surprising is that this is listed through Expedia. I am shocked they would allow themselves to be affiliated with such a property. It really makes me reconsider whether I can ever trust Expedia again. There was no ironing board, but even if there was, it would have been too filthy to use. There was no hairdryer. There was only one small lamp in a large, dark and dank room. The keys didn't work at least half the time but the AC and heat did, so we were lucky in that regard."