Shelter Island hotel guide. Wyndham Hotels hotel in Shelter Island, New York

"My stay was excellent from start to finish. Everything exceeded expectations — the staff was professional and welcoming, the room was clean and comfortable, and the overall atmosphere made the experience even better. Great service, smooth check-in, and attention to detail throughout. I would definitely stay here again and highly recommend this hotel. "

"Perfect for 1 night stay. Staff communicated perfectly."

"Great space with alot of on-site amenities. The hotel has vintage charm. "

"Great location, seemed a little outdated for the area. Breakfast was so so, didn't seem fresh. Late check-in was very helpful."

"Every thing was amazing food and drinks to the fire pits on the terrace area"

"Really liked the property and would have been fun in the summer. Bed was comfy and there was a nice steamer. My only complaint is just how small the bathroom was. Other rooms may have larger ones, but it was tiny and that could be an issue for some."

"Great views from the restaurant and bar area. Staff were very friendly and attentive. Will stay here again."

"The breakfast was delicious, the rooms were nice, and the bar was perfect. In all of my travels I think the staff at this hotel might be the nicest, most accommodating people I’ve ever met. They truly made our stay wonderful. Olga and the other front desk staff were amazing. "

"It was a good experience in general, definitely recommend and I would go back if I need to"