Search Cottages in Lower Matecumbe Key

"Amara Cay Resort is truly a slice of paradise! Our stay was absolutely perfect — from the moment we checked in, we were greeted by friendly, helpful staff who made us feel right at home. We stayed in an oceanfront hotel room, and the views were nothing short of breathtaking. Waking up to the sound of the waves and watching the sunrise from our balcony was a highlight of the trip. Huge thanks to the entire team at Amara Cay for creating such a memorable experience. We’ll definitely be back! "

"I have no complaints. We would definitely stay here again."

"Many rooms have a wonderful water view across a very nice beach. The dock is a great place to snorkel or fish from."

"The property was very nice and the room was updated. It had a big pool and an additional pool next to the bar. The property was clean and everyone was very friendly. We will definitely come back."

"The property is the best for family vacation and the staff is awesome "

"Excellent hidden gem in the keys !"

"The property is private and quiet. Its upscale and the staff, very professional. "

"Amazing!! "

"It was a very peaceful, friendly place. Would definitely recommend to anyone looking for a relaxing get away "