Search Beach Resorts & Hotels in Shelter Island Heights

"Was very nice used hotels.com saved alot for both rooms. Enkoyed the pool and spa hot tub was great. Pricy but worth it the view was beautiful "

"The hotel is in pretty rough shape. The sink rusted, the tub and mirror dirty. The garbage cans still had garbage from the previous guests. The only good part was the location "

"Clean room and staff is friendly "

"Breakfast is better than most chain hotels. Clean and friendly staff near lots of good food options. "

"This is a lovely motel located right on the Sound and all rooms face the water. The room was clean and relatively spacious, though most of the space was devoted to the kitchen and living areas. The bathroom was a bit small, as was the sleeping area. My family, including an elderly relative, traveled here for a family wedding in mid-April. The wedding was initially set to begin at 3:30 PM; check-in time is 4:00 PM. When I tried to arrange an earlier check-in time in advance, I was told that I would just have to take my chances because the motel was unwilling to guarantee an early check-in unless I also stayed the night before the wedding or paid a high hourly fee (i.e., roughly 1/3 of the room rate per hour of early check-in). Given that a significant percentage of the overnight guests were there for the wedding, and that one of the four rooms I reserved was for an elderly relative of the couple, I was taken aback by the motel management's rigidity. Fortunately, the couple was able to push back the time of the ceremony to accommodate their guests because the motel would not do so."

"The Montauk Yacht Club is a beautiful and relaxing getaway with a true coastal luxury feel. The property is well-maintained, with scenic waterfront views that make the entire experience feel special and refreshing. The rooms are comfortable and thoughtfully designed, offering a clean and modern aesthetic. The Service is generally attentive, and the overall vibe is calm yet upscale without feeling overly formal. It’s a great place for a weekend escape or a special occasion, especially if you enjoy being near the water. Overall: A stylish, peaceful retreat with a strong vacation vibe."

"I was first placed in a dirty room but they were very quick and efficient to move me which was great b/c I don’t like first floor rooms. In my second room on 2nd floor the window lock was broken so I couldn’t lock it. Uncomfortable but being in 2nd floor helped. Clock in the room nor working or unplugged?? Just used my fon for the clock. Breakfast area very clean and orderly and good. Parking lot had potholes but they were there fixing them today. Staff VERY friendly!!! "

"Clean room. Close to highway"

"I checked in during a severe snowstorm and had to leave the hotel within 30 minutes due to the conditions. Despite barely using the room, I was charged $304.50 as a “service fee.” I later reached out to the hotel to request clarification and a possible adjustment, but I have not received any response to this day. I understand that policies may apply, but charging such a significant amount for a stay of less than an hour—especially under unavoidable weather conditions—feels unreasonable and disappointing. The lack of communication from the hotel only adds to the frustration. I would appreciate a proper explanation and a fair resolution."