Search Holiday Rentals in Tingler Island

"The cottage is very cute, and very good stay overall "

"The place is amazing.. the pool front room was on point. The only thing I disliked was for the amount of money spent on the room (which was over $310, and I stayed 5 days) they did not provide breakfast. All meals need to be purchased and they are not cheap by any means. Now I will say that the food was amazing though."

"Centrally located! Beautiful property right on the bay. Nice restaurant on the premises. Small issue with housekeeping that was quickly resolved! Only con was the location to other restaurants or grocery store - a 15-20 minute ride to Islamorada or Marathon."

"Very nice room and view. Very clean. Enjoyed the pool and bar. Just had a problem with our toilet filling up. We enjoyed our stay though."

"great breakfast, menu could have some more options, pizza was amazing, just wish the restaurant stayed open later and the bar opened earlier, loved my stay! "

"This property is conveniently located right off US one in Marathon. My room faced the highway, so there was a lot of traffic noise, but that didn’t really bother me so much. My first evening on property, a man approached me in the parking lot and asked for money. That was offputting and a little frightening. I continued to walk past my room so he didn’t know where I was staying. That felt very unsafe. My car was parked just outside my room. It was about 830 at night so it was already dark outside. The room was large and spacious. Very clean, but no table for the sofa or any other desk or workspace. There’s certainly plenty of room to put some additional furniture. Bed linens were very nice. Plenty of towels. While the pool area seems well maintained and the furniture is very nice including the umbrellas, there was a distinct garbage smell the day I was at the pool, which was overpowering. There’s a lot of chickens running around the property near the pool, which didn’t bother me, but I could see how they would be intimidating to small children or folks who aren’t familiar with chickens and how they can be. There is no ice machine anywhere, but the lobby staff is happy to provide bags of ice for you if you ask. All in all, this was a great location for me to serve as a base while here in the keys.."

"Great breakfast, bed was comfortable, bathrooms were large. Great experience. "

"the room was dated there were holes in the walls from air conditioning repairs some of the paneling was coming off the wall shower valve was hard to use it didn't always work parking not assigned so sometimes I had to park in front of the next building "

"No soap, no nothing. Marina and Aqualodge smelled soooo bad like sewage. We could not stay in there. Moved to a house. Beds were really lumpy. Pool was closed the entire time we were there. Deer are adorable."