Cari Lodges di Barnum Island

"There were 2 hispanic women working the free breakfast. They were both extremely helpful to the guests and i observed them go out of their way on several occasions taking extra care of the guests. Additionally the breakfast area was always very clean, well stocked and these ladies did an excellent job. The cleaning staff were consistently friendly saying hello and asking if we needed anything. These employees made our vacation more enjoyable. We will be returning to this hotel"

"Room overall got the job done. Clean and a good size. We were in town for a family function and were discouraged from having a small (6 person) gathering in the common area on the first-floor seating area after the party. This was NOT late - it was around 6 or 7 PM. We were only looking to have conversations at a respectable volume, and we were the only other people there. We were told that they do not really want people using that space for this and at that point went and crammed into one...

"Clean hotel very nice room and In loved that the hotel is smoking free"

"Very nice property. Great staff."

"I could not stay because it false advertised. So I concealed my reservation upon see inside the facility."

"The room was clean. The bathroom was a good size and clean. They are the only hotel I've found that considers smokers. They have a covered area with benches for their smoking guests to use."

"The view from my room was great. I could see the New York skyline in the distance. The room itself was big and the bed was comfortable. The one problem was cleanliness. The toilet was blocked on my very first day, and there were still hairs on the towels when I arrived. That should not happen. The location works well though. The station is right across the street, and with the LIRR you get into NYC quite quickly."