Cari Hotel di Mackinac County

"Staying on the island is very cool. But unnecessarily expensive. Especially when everything else on the island is expensive."

"The inn is old so know you are going to hear people above you and doors closing. Very creaky floors. The check-in was ok. The woman was very rude. Not friendly and more interested in reading her paper. The young ladies later on in the day were smiley and friendly. Late afternoon check-in was nice dealing with them. Breakfast was good the gentleman is there watching and replacing items. Great location. Beautiful gardens. We did not use the pool. But bc we were close by heard all the noise. I...

"If you’re going to Mackinac Island stay in Mackinac City. St. Ignes is an older more run down city with nothing to do. Very limited restaurants and shops. Wish I would have known this as a first time visitor."

"We liked everything about the room and balcony but the breakfast served by the inhouse restaurant was extremely overpriced for the food we received. It was just okay. I wouldn't buy it again."

"The Cedar Hill Lodge was great for our party of 5 people for a one night stay. We were wanting a place to stay after crossing the Mackinac Bridge. This was a lovely newly renovated resort with lots of amenities. We stayed in room 252 which was in the Spruce building. We had the room with multiple beds and a balcony. The room was large, comfortable, clean, and worked perfect for us! The bathroom was clean and in good condition. The sink is outside of the bathroom which was very convenient for us...

"Rooms weren't cleaned and we didn't get towels a couple of the days we were there. Front desk is really nice and so is every maintenance person. We needed a maintenance person because we found out on day 2 the door was not locking."

"Really loved the vibe at Pine Cottage. Room was very clean and ours had a great view, comfortable mattress. Guests can relax on the porch chairs and the breakfast was great. Would stay again."

"The property is 1.7 miles from Main Street Downtown. The carriage rides take 30-40 minutes in/out of downtown, not easy to schedule, and $11/pp each way. We walked 21 miles while we were on Mackinac Island for 3 days. We booked a King with pullout but was never informed it was a handicapped room -bug disappointment. The shower leaked all over the floor (not designed and sealed well). There always seemed to be chaos with the staff. One morning we waited 1 hr for breakfast and last night we had no...

"Super charming hotel! The room was straight out of the era in which the hotel was built yet with a modern bathroom. Hotel is conveniently located in the middle of it all. Ample bicycle parking near by. Hot tub was a nice distraction on a day we weren't sure what to do. Also the porch chairs were a perfect spot to people watch. Be sure to grab your breakfast donut in the morning on your way out to enjoy the island- it's very good! (The photo is the view from our room)"

"The best hotel we have ever stayed."

"Friendly and professional staff. Tremendous view! Good breakfast. This hotel will now be our home base for all future trips to St. Ignace and Mackinaw Straits region"

"No internet. No ability to cast to tv or use apps. Basic cable only. A brand be Phillips Google TV, with basic cable only. Odd for 2026. The carpet in our room was wet near the tub. It had a blower when we went in and never fully dried. Really wish the Expedia deal had not been non-refundable"

"Our room was very clean with the exception of several days worth of dead bugs on the balcony. (Lake facing, lots of bugs daily). Breakfast was as expected, chicken sausage patties for the meat choice, would have preferred a second pork selection. Great public decks, bar and lounge. Plenty of outdoor space for our dog. We would stay here again."

"We drove up and knew right away. We had picked the wrong hotel. The pool was closed and the hot tub and construction stuff all around it. It just looked awful. The room was OK but nothing spectacular. The beach was horrendous and not even worth walking on. We were supposed to say for three days and only stayed one night and left the next day and was not issued any refund, stay away!"

"Be warned! Many rooms do not have Air conditioning, and they do not make this obvious or noticeable in the listings! 84 degrees in my Deluxe Suite at night, no fans, no offer for a portable unit, worst uncomfortable stay of my life."

"Great experience! Very clean and updated."

"We have stayed at this location a few times and it has always been excellent. We would stay again"

"Hotel is in a decent location and it is clean. Lake and Mackinaw Island views from the room are nice too. The property is old however and could use some updating particularly the lakeside (peeling trim, etc.)."

"Rooms smelly and not well kept ! Musty smell ! We were given room on first floor which is usually for pets"

"Na"