Search Cottages in Plum Island

"My daughter and I had a lovely 4 night stay at The Renwick. It’s a great location - about a 5 minute walk from Grand Central and on a quiet street (for Manhattan). The room was huge with 2 very comfortable double beds and a balcony (room 1506). Also, free bottles of water in the room each day. The staff were very friendly and although we didn’t eat in the hotel, the restaurant and bar was always busy which is a good sign. If we’re visiting again, we’d definitely stay there again. "

"Only major issue was parking other then that it was okay "

"better than I expected, nice staff, room is nice, good amenities, would definitely come back, my favorite hotel in NY so far "

"We had a great time here and well located"

"No wifi, just elevator functionality for 2 week… not the Ace I was used to. Staff all ways good though "

"Staff is great. Rooms are clean although outdated. Hotel is on a busy corner so you hear the traffic noises. All in all, a great price for the location and we would stay here again. "

"Front desk staff was so friendly and accommodating. Can’t wait to come back. Also the water pressure in the shower was incredible!!!"

"Perfect stay! "

"This hotel is very aesthetically pleasing, with a trendy, photo-ready bar and lobby—there were multiple people doing photoshoots during our stay. That said, the first thing you notice is a strong perfume scent throughout the first floor. At first I thought it was other guests, but it’s actually the hotel itself. The downstairs areas look great but can feel crowded depending on how busy it is (though that may just be part of being in New York). The overall vibe leans toward a younger, party-focused crowd. Between the suggestive artwork and the club right next to the entrance, it doesn’t feel very family-friendly. The elevator system requires you to tap and select your floor before entering. It works fine once you figure it out, but it’s not intuitive—I saw multiple guests struggle with it. Our room was nice, but didn’t match what we booked. We paid for a king with a city view but got a queen with a partial view that mostly overlooked a daycare. When we asked, we were told some rooms don’t actually have a full view, so keep that in mind. Also, we found a dried contact lens on the floor, which was concerning. Overall, great aesthetic, but better suited for a younger, nightlife-oriented crowd than families or quieter travelers."