Plum Island hotel guide. Highgate Independent hotel in Plum Island, New Jersey

" Property was amazing "

"Super fun decor/ vibe. The space is a little tight- but not unmanageably so. "

"We had a great stay. Location is great and accessible to many attractions and monuments. Clean and friendly staff."

"I love it"

"My overall stay had been really comfortable. I liked the wide clean lobby. Didn’t use the pool or had breakfast, though. I wanted latte in the morning, but they had those instant cream packets. Hot americano is available. I guess the only downside for me was that it has grey carpet floor and I have no idea if the floor is clean or not (smells like a clean old hotel, but it didn’t smell moldy or unclean), and the only way out is via Uber/Lyft inside a narrow forest-y road that Doordash can never find."

"Very welcoming staff on the reception desk, especially Ami who made us feel very comfortable and did the best she could to get us an early check in.The friendliness and courtesy from the staff managing the breakfast area on the other hand could do with some improvement.At times we almost felt discriminated given that one particular staff member chose to completely ignore our presence while chatting away heartily to other guests.Other than this experience I can’t rate this hotel highly enough!!"

"Friendly staff great stay seamless process "

"Wonderful staff "