Plum Island hotel guide. Highgate Independent hotel in Plum Island, New Jersey

"Excellent "

"everything "

"Great location "

"Underwhelming "

"The perfect location! Staff is super great! Rooms are good size and clean! Definitely will stay here again!"

"Everything perfectl"

"The hotel has many stores nearby. The location is great. The bagels at breakfast were delicious, and the staff was friendly."

"Basically, you get what you pay for! For this price in this location, I think it’s the best that you can get. Just know that the room is very small, no real amenities other than basic necessities, and small windows. But if you just need a safe and private place to crash while still being in a central area, then this is a great option! "

"I had to move from my original room because the heater wasn't working. In the second room, the wifi didn't work, and the toilet pipes emitted a loud noise every 30 minutes. Additionally, coffee was advertised as included with the $30-a-night amenities fee at the front desk, but I was still charged separately. This was confusing. Despite these issues, all the staff were incredibly kind. The problems I experienced were operational and structural, not related to the staff."